Incredible Pizza Menu With Prices For 2026
Walking into Incredible Pizza is an instant assault on your senses: the warm, yeasty aroma of freshly baked dough, the vibrant swirl of salad bar colors, and the unmistakable sizzle of bubbling cheese beckon hungry guests of all ages. Known for its all-you-can-eat buffet, Incredible Pizza serves up a dizzying variety of options that extend far beyond just pizza. Families, friends, and parties flock here for both the spread and the entertainment — it’s more than just a meal, it’s an experience.
The heart and soul of Incredible Pizza is their expansive buffet, where classic and inventive pizzas line up alongside comforting pastas, custom salads, and satisfyingly sweet treats. Regulars love the fact that you’ll find family-friendly favorites like pepperoni and cheese, but are just as likely to stumble across surprise hits such as Taco Pizza and creamy Alfredo pastas. You truly never know what fresh combination you’ll find next.
With updated offerings for 2026, the Incredible Pizza menu promises value, quality, and lots of fun. Choosing what to eat is almost as entertaining as the arcade next door. Whether you're a parent looking to please picky eaters or a large group with varied tastes, the Incredible Pizza menu has something for everyone — and with buffet pricing, every visit brings the freedom to indulge and explore.
Incredible Pizza Buffet Menu With Prices
Dive into the Incredible Pizza Buffet Menu With Prices below to discover the latest options for 2026. From pizza classics to sides, pastas, salads, and sweet desserts, this buffet offers a feast that’s both family-friendly and budget-friendly — perfect for bringing everyone together over a satisfying meal.
Pizza Creations
The heart of the buffet is, of course, the pizza. Incredible Pizza showcases a vibrant lineup of hand-tossed creations made with their signature dough and golden, gooey cheese. Each pie is baked fresh in-store, ensuring that every slice is piping hot, with that irresistible pull of mozzarella stretching from pan to plate.
Classics such as pepperoni, sausage, and cheese satisfy purists, but the menu thrives on creativity. Buffalo Chicken, Taco Pizza, and Veggie Garden showcase a mix of bold flavors, drawing in guests who crave something more than basic slices. Each pizza caters to different taste preferences and are rotated regularly, so return visits are always rewarded with new discoveries.
Crust options remain reliably popular — from thin and crispy to thick and chewy, giving guests the power to choose their perfect base. And for guests with dietary needs, the ever-growing range includes gluten-friendly and vegetarian options, making sure everyone at the party feels right at home.
With most pizzas ranging from 180 to 350 calories per slice and included in the price of admission, it’s a guilt-free invitation to try several varieties. The ever-present aroma is a constant reminder why pizza will always be the star of the show, and many visitors cite Incredible Pizza menu as their all-time favorite for sheer variety and freshness.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Pepperoni Pizza | $9.99 | 300 |
| Cheese Pizza | $8.99 | 270 |
| Taco Pizza | $11.49 | 340 |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza | $10.99 | 320 |
| Supreme Pizza | $11.99 | 350 |
| Veggie Garden Pizza | $9.49 | 240 |
| Meat Lovers Pizza | $12.49 | 380 |
| BBQ Chicken Pizza | $10.99 | 330 |
| Hawaiian Pizza | $10.49 | 300 |
| Alfredo Spinach Pizza | $9.99 | 310 |
Signature Pastas
The pasta bar at Incredible Pizza is a hidden gem often praised by regulars. Forget bland noodles — here, pastas are freshly cooked throughout the day and tossed in a selection of rich sauces to satisfy every craving. Rotini, penne, and spaghetti form the base, all cooked perfectly and awaiting your choice of savory toppings.
Sauce options are extensive: creamy Alfredo for those who love a rich, decadent bite; hearty marinara loaded with Italian herbs; and robust meat sauce that brings protein and a satisfying texture. The triple cheese baked ziti is a cheese-lovers’ dream, bubbling from the oven with a browned, bubbly top.
These pastas are designed to complement the pizza offerings, not overshadow them, meaning portion sizes are generous but reasonable. Each serving ranges from 220 to 450 calories, so diners can sample several kinds without worry. Many guests find that their favorite plates are unexpected combos — a little Alfredo, a little red sauce, and a smattering of meatballs.
Priced to be accessible, the pasta dishes are included in the buffet structure. The customization makes it a hit for families with different tastes or picky eaters who want total control over their meals, making the Incredible Pizza menu especially appealing in 2026.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Classic Spaghetti with Marinara | $3.99 | 220 |
| Three-Cheese Baked Ziti | $4.49 | 340 |
| Fettuccine Alfredo | $4.29 | 410 |
| Meatball Marinara Spaghetti | $4.99 | 390 |
| Rotini Primavera | $4.19 | 270 |
| Penne with Meat Sauce | $4.75 | 370 |
| Chicken Alfredo Penne | $5.19 | 450 |
| Cheesy Macaroni | $3.89 | 320 |
Fresh Salad Bar
The salad bar is a crisp, colorful oasis for both health-conscious diners and those craving a refreshing start before the heartier items. Greens are replenished constantly, ensuring every scoop is cool and crunchy. Romaine, spring mix, and iceberg serve as a base for an array of options — from cherry tomatoes and carrots to sunflower seeds and crunchy croutons.
Over a dozen dressings are available, including low-fat and vegan options. The creamy ranch and zesty Italian are firm favorites, but adventurous eaters often reach for honey mustard or tangy blue cheese. Guests are invited to build simple salads or assemble loaded plates with cheese, hard-boiled eggs, and diced ham or grilled chicken.
The Fresh Salad Bar is included in the buffet price and is perfect for balancing out slices of pizza or plates of pasta. With so much choice, every diner can tailor their meal to personal dietary needs or flavor preferences. A standard serving, rich with veggies and modest toppings, clocks in under 200 calories.
Kids and adults alike return for seconds, and the option to go light before indulging in other riches is one reason why the Incredible Pizza menu has built a reputation for true all-ages appeal.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Create-Your-Own Salad | $4.29 | 150 |
| Garden Fresh Salad | $4.49 | 140 |
| Caesar Salad | $4.99 | 170 |
| Chef Salad | $5.49 | 240 |
| Greek Salad | $5.29 | 210 |
| Buffalo Chicken Salad | $5.59 | 320 |
| Southwest Chopped Salad | $5.49 | 290 |
| Vegetarian Power Bowl | $5.29 | 180 |
Classic Sides
No buffet experience at Incredible Pizza would be complete without sampling their lineup of classic sides. These offerings are the perfect snackable addition — salty, crispy, and thoughtfully seasoned to complement heavier dishes. Garlic breadsticks emerge hot from the oven, their edges browned and interiors soft as pillows.
Potato lovers rejoice with freshly made mashed potatoes and creamy country-style gravy, while crispy, cheese-laden tater tots are a hit among younger diners. Onion rings and mozzarella sticks add a hint of nostalgia and a satisfying crunch to each plate.
Every side is designed to round out your meal without overshadowing the main attractions. Most range from 130 to 280 calories per serving, so you can sample a few with minimal guilt. Sides are served buffet-style for easy mixing and matching.
Regulars know that combining sides with salad or pizza can create some surprisingly satisfying flavor pairings, making the Incredible Pizza menu a destination for both classic and creative eaters.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Garlic Breadsticks | $2.49 | 180 |
| Mashed Potatoes & Gravy | $2.99 | 170 |
| Crispy Tater Tots | $2.79 | 220 |
| Golden Onion Rings | $3.59 | 210 |
| Mozzarella Sticks | $3.99 | 250 |
| Sweet Corn Medley | $2.49 | 140 |
| Mac & Cheese Bites | $3.29 | 280 |
| Crispy French Fries | $2.79 | 190 |
Desserts & Sweet Treats
Dessert at Incredible Pizza is a spectacle in itself, worthy of its own trip through the buffet line. The aroma of warm, sugar-dusted cinnamon rolls and freshly baked cookies is enough to lure diners back for seconds (and sometimes thirds). These feature soft centers, just-baked edges, and generous drizzles of icing.
Brownie chunks, chocolate cake, and fruit cobbler provide comforting, old-fashioned flavors, delivering sweetness without being cloying. On the lighter side, there’s chilled pudding and a selection of fresh seasonal fruit, perfect for those looking for a sweet finishing touch that won’t tip the calorie scale.
Soft-serve ice cream remains an enduring favorite — swirl together chocolate and vanilla, top with rainbow sprinkles or crushed cookies, and craft your own perfect sundae. These treats typically range from 110 to 320 calories per serving and are all included as part of the buffet access.
The dessert station is particularly kid-friendly, but with flavors and nostalgia for adults as well. It’s this diverse appeal that makes the Incredible Pizza menu a true crowd-pleaser, especially when the sweet finale brings everyone to the table for one last taste.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Cinnamon Sugar Rolls | $2.59 | 210 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookies | $1.99 | 140 |
| Brownie Squares | $2.49 | 180 |
| Soft Serve Ice Cream (cup or cone) | $2.29 | 170 |
| Seasonal Fruit Cup | $2.09 | 110 |
| Warm Chocolate Cake | $2.79 | 320 |
| Old-Fashioned Bread Pudding | $2.39 | 240 |
| Berry Cobbler | $2.49 | 200 |
Beverages & Fountains
Wash down your meal with a full selection of beverages at Incredible Pizza. The self-serve fountain station features everything from classic colas to fruity punches and lemonades, with both regular and diet options. Each beverage is ice cold and perfectly carbonated, ideal for resetting your palate between savory or sweet bites.
For coffee lovers, hot brews and decaf are always available, paired perfectly with a cinnamon roll or chocolate chip cookie from the dessert bar. Kids enjoy unlimited refills with their meals, running back for another splash of fruit punch or a half-and-half mix of sodas.
Bottled juices and milk complete the lineup for guests who want something a bit different, especially for young children or anyone looking for a caffeine-free option. Most drinks land between 0 and 160 calories per serving, so you can hydrate to your liking.
Beverages are included in certain package prices or can be purchased separately for around $2.79. The flexibility and variety make this the perfect finishing touch to the Incredible Pizza menu and keep guests satisfied from first bite to last sip.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Fountain Soda (unlimited refills) | $2.79 | 140 |
| Iced Tea | $2.59 | 0 |
| Lemonade | $2.59 | 120 |
| Fruit Punch | $2.59 | 130 |
| Bottled Water | $1.99 | 0 |
| Bottled Apple Juice | $2.49 | 110 |
| Cold Milk | $2.39 | 90 |
| Hot Coffee | $2.49 | 5 |
Does Incredible Pizza Have Sugar-Free Options?
Yes, Incredible Pizza does offer sugar-free options for guests looking to monitor their sugar intake. On the salad bar, you'll find a variety of fresh vegetables and dressings that are low in sugar, and select beverages like diet sodas and unsweetened iced tea are always available. While most desserts are sweet, sometimes sugar-free gelatin or pudding is featured, and fruit cups are a smart, naturally sweet alternative.
For guests seeking alternatives to traditional sugary treats, it's wise to stick to the salad and fresh fruit selections as dessert. Always check the daily offerings at the buffet, as some locations may rotate sugar-free items like diet desserts or no-sugar-added pies. It's also helpful to ask staff about current sugar-free options — they're usually happy to point out what's available that day, especially as menu choices grow each year.
If you’re visiting with dietary restrictions, plan ahead by calling your local Incredible Pizza or checking their online menu to see what's available for your needs. Pair unsweetened iced tea with your meal and fill up on protein-rich salad bar options to avoid sugary temptations. Combining these strategies will ensure you enjoy your visit to the fullest while keeping sugar in check.
FAQs
What are the current buffet prices at Incredible Pizza?
For 2026, buffet prices at Incredible Pizza generally range from $12.99 to $17.99 for adults and $8.99 to $11.99 for children, depending on location and day of the week.
Special discounts are often available for seniors, toddlers, or family groups, and package deals may include unlimited drinks and game credits. Always check your local store’s pricing before visiting.
Are there vegetarian and gluten-free pizza options?
Yes, Incredible Pizza offers both vegetarian and gluten-friendly pizza options every day. Look for clearly labeled pies like Veggie Garden and gluten-friendly cheese pizza on the buffet.
Although the kitchen is not fully gluten-free, measures are taken to reduce cross-contamination. Always inform staff if you have a severe allergy so appropriate care can be taken.
Do they accommodate food allergies?
Incredible Pizza works to provide ingredient information and support for guests with allergies. Staff are trained to answer questions and direct guests to suitable options on the menu.
However, because items are prepared in a shared kitchen, cross-contact can occur. Notify the manager about any severe allergies to receive the best possible guidance during your visit.
Is there a takeout or to-go option for the buffet?
While the buffet is predominantly for dine-in enjoyment, some locations allow guests to pay by weight and build a takeout box. Selection may be more limited for to-go orders.
It’s a good idea to call ahead and ask about current to-go options at your specific Incredible Pizza location, as policies and offerings can vary and may change seasonally.
Are drinks included in the buffet price?
Depending on your chosen package and location, drinks may be included in the buffet or charged separately. Unlimited self-serve fountain drinks are often bundled with premium buffet packages.
If drinks are not included, you can always purchase them at the standard beverage price. Be sure to confirm with staff at your location when you arrive to avoid surprises.
What desserts are available at Incredible Pizza?
You’ll find a tempting dessert buffet at Incredible Pizza featuring cinnamon rolls, cookies, brownies, ice cream, pudding, cakes, and fresh fruit. Dessert options rotate throughout the day.
All desserts are included in the buffet price, so you can sample a variety as part of your meal. Some locations also feature sugar-free dessert options or specialty treats for holidays.
Conclusion
The Incredible Pizza menu is designed to satisfy cravings across all ages, offering an expansive mix of pizza, pastas, salads, sides, desserts, and drinks. Whether you’re stopping in for a family celebration or a casual night out, their all-you-can-eat buffet promises great value with a huge variety of dishes. It’s this blend of choice and abundance that keeps guests coming back year after year.
If you’re visiting Incredible Pizza, don’t miss their Pizza Creations — especially the Taco Pizza and Supremes. The Signature Pastas and Desserts & Sweet Treats categories also stand out, with fan favorites like Three-Cheese Baked Ziti and cinnamon sugar rolls. The Fresh Salad Bar provides healthy, customizable options that make any visit well-rounded and memorable.
The Incredible Pizza menu is the perfect choice when you need to please a group or simply crave a feast of endless taste possibilities. Visit with an open mind and empty stomach, and be ready to try a bit of everything — it’s the best way to discover your own favorites from this fun and flavorful spread.
